mean_liar wrote:And that is much better than, "all 40 mothers have a social obligation to have their kids aborted".
The only real question deals with those 10 that you feel are going to not be aborted naturally. Your response is to abort them all, knowing that half are going to be functioning adults and 3 are going to be poorly-functioning people that are an economic drag.
That you don't see that as a problem is something you might want to consider from a different viewpoint from your own.
Who else is on the eugenics chopping block, Frank? Where's the line?
No. It doesn't have to do with the 10 whose bodies would fail to abort the fetus, all 40 of them will continue to have a fetus in them under a potentially life threatening danger of spontaneous abortion for
months. The ones who are going to abort naturally would still benefit immensely by having earlier and safer abortions in a hospital setting. Assuming that they want children, they would be able to do that sooner and run less risks with tearing up their uterus.
But what you're persistently not getting is that Down Syndrome isn't even a eugenics question. It's a birth defect. Like fetal alcohol syndrome. It's something that happens to a single child and more than likely
if they grow up to be able to have children of their own, those childen would just be normal children.
The question is incredibly simple
because it doesn't effect the long term genetic makeup of humanity either way. It's
just a matter of whether you want to roll the dice and have the 1 in 4 chance of successfully bringing the fetus all the way to term to have the 50% chance of having a baby that would grow up to be able to make a birthday wish on their 18th birthday.
Or take an extra 3 months to have child that's healthy. If you roll those dice, you're an idiot and a monster. There's no genetic diversity to conserve, no eugenic burden. Just the slow and safe route vs. the quick and dangerous route that will permanently cripple your child even if it "works."
How important is your child's birthday?
-Username17